Top 10 Vehicles Causing the Most Accidents Published on June 20, 2023 in Top 10 by The Car Guide Photo: Subaru 7. Subaru Crosstrek Percentage of owners with at least one at-fault accident on their record: 10.5% The Crosstrek shares many components with the Impreza. Just like the latter, it is completely redesigned for 2024, as pictured above.